Facebook isn't supposed to let advertisers target by things like age or Watch Carnal Sins (2001) full moviegender for employment ads anymore, but a new study showed that the social network's ad algorithm is doing it anyway.
More than two years after Facebook disabled that particular feature for housing and employment listings, researchers at the University of Southern California found that certain job listings mysteriously still show a noticeable skew in who sees them. The study's findings would be illegal under federal employment discrimination law.
"Our system takes into account many signals to try and serve people ads they will be most interested in, but we understand the concerns raised in the report," a Facebook spokesperson said in a statement responding to the study, shared with Mashable. "We’ve taken meaningful steps to address issues of discrimination in ads and have teams working on ads fairness today. We're continuing to work closely with the civil rights community, regulators, and academics on these important matters."
To understand the study, one must first understand an interesting carve-out in Title VII, the U.S. law that prohibits employment discrimination on the basis of race, gender, and so on. Employers are still technically allowed to hire based on "bona fide occupational qualifications." That means a company that makes men's clothing is legally allowed to only consider men for modeling positions, when that would be discrimination in most other fields.
While previous studies that reached the same conclusion about Facebook's ad algorithms used different methodology, the USC study focused on this by creating job listings for jobs that exhibit real-life gender demographic skews despite no real difference in qualifications. For example, Domino's Pizza delivery drivers are overwhelmingly male while Instacart grocery deliverers are predominantly female, per the study.
When the researchers created job listings for Domino's drivers and Instacart shoppers and ran them at the same time to the same audiences, the former were largely delivered to men and the latter to women by Facebook's backend advertising technology.
SEE ALSO: How to check if hackers are sharing your Facebook dataThis held true even with listings for software engineer and retail sales associate jobs that also carry the same real-life gender skew. Even when choosing to optimize the ad campaign for the most possible views (as opposed to the most likely click-throughs, another option Facebook offers advertisers), the gender gap still persisted. Interestingly, none of this happened when the same methodology was applied to LinkedIn's listing service.
We've known for years that Facebook's job ads technology allows for direct or indirect discrimination like this, but the fact that it still happens like this without human intervention years after Facebook promised to do better is concerning. Finding good work is difficult enough without some faceless algorithm keeping job listings away from you on the basis of your identity.
Topics Facebook Gender
Clean energy projects soared in 2016 as solar and wind got cheaper
The Arctic is reeling from its warmest year since at least 1900
Rick Perry vowed to scrap the Energy Department. Now he may lead it.
Top Google searches show this nation's citizens had a v. v. odd 2016
Best Dyson deal: Save over $100 on Dyson V11 Origin cordless vacuum
Donald Trump believed a WWE storyline which explains a lot
Microsoft's version of the Amazon Echo will be a Cortana
Hundreds of tech workers pledge to fight a Muslim registry
$800 off an LG TV at Best Buy
No more hazing MLB rookies by making them dress as women
How to survive Valentine's Day when you're heartbroken
These are the hottest trends for 2017 according to Pinterest
One dad was so confused by 'Pokémon Go' he made a short film about it
Man sparks possibly the world's greatest Wiki photo caption battle
HDMI 2.2 set to be announced at CES 2025
28 gift ideas for people who can’t believe how shitty 2016 was
Google reportedly scales down its self
Oklahoma's public bathrooms will soon be forced to post anti
Segway Xyber is a wickedly quick e
No more hazing MLB rookies by making them dress as women
62 fashion icons deliver strong message about the importance of womenEmma Watson's book fairies are hiding feminist books all over the worldSXSW Interactive is still the most valuable business weekend of the yearTinder offers $100 donations in honor of Women's Day'Taboo' renewed, aka more Tom Hardy on your TVHow the expanded Nemesis System will work in the ‘Shadow of Mordor’ sequelNew report claims the next iPhone might be called 'iPhone Edition'Facebook hosts 24Man arrested for destroying multiple copies of Kim Kardashian's selfie bookHow a drone helped firefighters battle a blaze in New York CityWho's Behind the Massive Wikileaks Dump? The CIA Would Like to Know'Overwatch' will ban you if you use custom games to farm XPThe reasons women are striking across the globeGet an early look at 2017's 'League of Legends' April Fool's Day skinsTinder is testing a secret version of the app for the rich, famous and hotJ.K. Rowling reminds us all of Donald Trump's remarks about women'Overwatch' will ban you if you use custom games to farm XPCompanies will have to prove equal pay in Iceland now, and it's pretty greatNeed another reason to cut CO2? Oceans will suffer, study saysTrump's favorite techie thinks there should be 'more open debate' on global warming Jenna Fischer says 'The Office' Season 3 finale has an alternate ending 'Hyrule Warriors: Age of Calamity' is an excessive Zelda spin iFixit teardown confirms Apple's M1 MacBooks are basically the same as their predecessors There's a Sexy Jon Snow costume because Halloween is coming 'Star Wars: Tales from the Galaxy’s Edge' VR delivers what Disney’s theme parks can’t Elon Musk's pile of money is now bigger than Bill Gates's pile of money 'Myst' (yes, that 'Myst') is coming back as an Oculus VR game in December Rainn Wilson wants you to get serious about the fight against climate change Bitcoin is on the verge of surpassing its all That total eclipse thing totally messed with porn traffic DHS cybersecurity director subtweets Trump after being fired via tweet Netflix's "The Crown" recreated these real Princess Diana outfits Teardown of iPhone 12 Pro Max reveals big battery, big camera sensor 'The Mandalorian' Season 2 episode 4 reveals a truly sinister plot We read Obama's 'A Promised Land' so you don't have to, but you should The Wander app is a nostalgic Wayback Machine for VR The pet toy massacres of 'Toy Story' must be stopped Animals cared way less about the eclipse than we wanted them to Everything coming to Hulu in December 2020 Meet the Disloyal Man, star of the internet's new favorite meme
1.6855s , 10139.25 kb
Copyright © 2025 Powered by 【Watch Carnal Sins (2001) full movie】,Inspiration Information Network