X (formerly Twitter) takes swift action when taking down deepfake nude images that are Italyreported as copyright violations — but not when they're reported under "nonconsensual nudity," a study has found.
The paper, published by researchers at the University of Michigan and Florida International University, is an audit of X's reporting systems and hasn't yet been peer-reviewed, 404 Media reported. Researchers created five AI "personas" of young white women (to prevent further variables of race, gender, and age) and then made 10 replica images of each, resulting in 50 images. In terms of the ethics around generating deepfake porn themselves, researchers said these images underwent a "rigorous verification process" to ensure they didn't represent an existing individual.
SEE ALSO: How Big Tech is approaching explicit, nonconsensual deepfakesThey posted these images to X on 10 "poster accounts" they created, and then they created five X accounts to report the images. Twenty-five images were reported as Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) violations, and the other 25 were reported as nonconsensual nudity.
Researchers then waited three weeks to see the results of these reports. All 25 images reported for copyright were removed from X within 25 hours. In contrast, none of the images reported for nonconsensual nudity were removed within the three-week waiting period.
"Our findings reveal a significant disparity in the effectiveness of content removal processes between reports made under the DMCA and those made under X's internal nonconsensual nudity policy," the study states. "This highlights the need for stronger and directed regulations and protocols to protect victim-survivors."
X owner Elon Musk dissolved the platform's trust and safety council in 2022, but the site has recently opened up two dozen safety and cybersecurity positions in the U.S. Mashable has reached out to X for comment.
Earlier this year, WIRED found that victims of nonconsensual deepfake porn leveraged copyright laws to take down deepfakes on Google.
If you have had intimate images shared without your consent, call the Cyber Civil Rights Initiative’s 24/7 hotline at 844-878-2274 for free, confidential support. The CCRI website also includes helpful informationas well as a list of international resources.
Topics Social Good X/Twitter
Boeing's new VR simulator immerses astronauts in space training
An Interview with Jana Prikryl
3 bizarre Meta Quest 3 sightings we've seen out in the wild
Georgia Houghton’s “Spirit Drawings” Were Ahead of Their Time
Study trains Port Jackson sharks to respond to jazz music
'Quordle' today: See each 'Quordle' answer and hints for October 19, 2023
Small Talk Is America’s Greatest, Strangest Art Form
Intimisms: “Psychologic Poetry in Painting”
The State of PC Gaming in 2016
The best products that have gone viral so far in 2022
Every MCU movie villain ranked, from "Iron Man" to "Thunderbolts*"
Nichelle Nichols, Lt. Uhura from 'Star Trek', has died
Bill Berkson, 1939–2016
Can Poets Save the Parks? Well … Maybe.
Comparing Team Communication Apps: What Do You Get for Free?
Revisited: Elliott Smith, Either/Or
University of Alabama rush week begins on TikTok
Intimisms: “Psychologic Poetry in Painting”
LAFC vs. Colorado Rapids 2025 livestream: Watch Concacaf Champions Cup for free
“Catch the Heavenly Bodies”: 4 Paintings by Jay Miriam
Drinking in a canoe is illegal in Canada, but that could soon changeEverything coming to HBO Max in February 2021Hefner's son is embarrassed that Trump made Playboy's coverHow to decide if you should confront that annoying coworkerCheck out Black History Month events online'Passing' is a riveting exploration of identity: Movie reviewTrump to Puerto Rico: Show us the moneyEverything coming to HBO Max in February 20213 scientists win Nobel Prize in medicine for biological clock researchJeff Bezos as Amazon scandals, a threadApple will invest $3.6 billion in Kia Motors to build an Apple Car, report saysTesla recalls nearly 135,000 Model S and X cars because of failing touchscreensMayor of San Juan responds to Trump: "We have one goal, it is to save lives"Malala is off to college and needs your packing advice'A Glitch in the Matrix' digs into simulation theory: Movie reviewElon Musk is taking a break from Twitter againHelen Mirren and Jane Fonda casually slayed the runway at Fashion WeekHow to set a sleep timer in iOS for Netflix, Hulu or any streaming appHungry skunk got into a sticky McSituation, but one officer came to the rescueTwitter thinks it knows why Jeff Bezos stepped down as Amazon CEO 'Sacred Games' Season 2 is superfluous but brilliant Everything coming to (and going from) Hulu in September 2019 Rare photos show Obama girls on their first visit to the White House Arsonist pet tortoise starts fire that burns neighbor's home and causes $150,000 in damage July was the hottest month in 140 years of record Makeup blogger's dad nails anti Have you stared deeply into the Cat’s Eye Nebula? The internet is fact Oppo to launch Reno2 flagship with 20x zoom this month No, Facebook isn't getting rid of your secret group 'Legion' fades out with oddly peaceful finale This viral photo of lemons could save your life Inflatable Xbox One controller is perfect if you ever manage to go outside China claimed its troops can reach New Delhi in 48 hours and everyone cracked the same joke Maisie Williams makes Twitter request, gets more than she bargained for Mark Hamill turns Trump's Meryl Streep tweets into a psychotic Joker monologue Major security flaw exposes fingerprints of more than 1 million people Thanks to Trump, Rep. John Lewis is dominating Amazon's bestsellers list Justin Bieber's selfies (and bangs) are back After Trump's comments, the wrong John Lewis is getting buried in tweets